Popcorn seasoning (for those fun movie nights)
Matching T-shirts
A grill brush
A new toolbox
His favorite brand of shaving cream
Habañero sauce
New pens
A new planner
An Audible subscription
His favorite brand of tea or coffee
An apple/potato peeler
A Best Buy, Harbor Freight or Bass Pro Shop gift card
A heated foot warmer
A pancake griddle
Tickets to a baseball game
Movie tickets
An ice cream date with his favorite kid (you!)
A game of mini golf
A day of fishing
A new deck of cards
A board game
Sunglasses
A personalized keychain
His new favorite coffee mug
A daddy-daughter or daddy-son date to Home Depot