It is that time of year! Pumpkin spice everything surrounds us, autumn leaves have changed, the weather is finally cooler, and Thanksgiving is rapidly approaching. Folks look forward to Thanksgiving ¦ a time to savor good food and family togetherness. However, throwing a picky eater or two into the mix can make this holiday a little less than you bargained for. Traditions may abound, but perhaps this year calls for a little creativity and patience so everyone can enjoy the feast!
There are many ways picky eaters can be included in-and enjoy-the Thanksgiving festivities. First and foremost, realize you only have so much control over the food-and pretty much none over your picky eater. If you are hosting and preparing the food, you have control in your hands over what you are serving, so you can be more accommodating. However, if you are doing dinner potluck-style or someone else is hosting, you may have to just do the best you can. Follow along for a few tips to help things go as smoothly as possible and keep everyone feeling thankful.
- Include your picky eater in the planning of the Thanksgiving meal. Maybe he doesn’t really love the cream-style corn, but peas are his jam. Have both this year! Perhaps your finicky eater really loves rolls. Why not let her choose which kind you are serving? And almost all kids love dessert, so let your child decide what dessert options to serve!
- Have your picky eater get in on the cooking action. Sometimes kids are more apt to eat something if they have had a hand in preparing and cooking the food. Kids are able to take pride in managing tasks where they can have responsibility. Hilary Bair, Overland Park mom of three, shares, “I have picky eaters, and I do encourage them to help me cook the foods for Thanksgiving, as this will sometimes get them more excited to try what they have helped prepare.”
- Consider serving a buffet. This way everyone, not just the picky eaters, can be in charge of his plate, what is on it and how much is taken. If attending a potluck-style feast, make sure you are in charge of bringing at least one dish your picky eater enjoys and will be sure to eat. For our family, that is jellied cranberries, rolls and fruit salad!
- Try something new. Bair says, “I always tell my kids it is a great time of year to try the foods that make up some of our family traditions. And you might be surprised that you like certain foods too!”
- Include alternative meat options. Our kids are not huge fans of turkey but enjoy ham in limited bits, sausage and tenderloin. Oftentimes, we serve turkey and tenderloin, so they can have a protein option they enjoy more and will actually eat.
- The simpler the better sometimes. Strip down all the fancy, saucy, complicated food and include plain mashed potatoes, raw sliced veggies with dip or plain pasta (or even some good ol’ Kraft macaroni and cheese if that is what your kid is into).
- If you go this route, consider a mashed potato bar where guests can doctor their mashed potatoes with toppings on their own: cheese, butter, sour cream, bacon, gravy, whatever appeals. This way you still have the plain option, but also a food that people can customize to their own liking.
- Try to let go of cultural and societal expectations. Do what works for you and your family, even if it might be a little bit different then the norm. As difficult as it is, ignore disapproving glances and comments.
- Eat outside the box! Instead of traditional Thanksgiving meal options, be bold and cook up something totally different this year. We know families that have lasagna, taco or potato bars, or a soup potluck for their Thanksgiving meal. There are no written rules about what you can and can’t have!
- “Holiday meals can be stressful, so I try to keep things simple. I always place a small amount of foods they don’t typically eat (three bites to be polite!) and load up the things they love. It’s a fine balance between keeping Mom happy and kids happy,” says Overland Park mom of three Tara Lowery. “As long as they get some protein and veggies in-win-win! The real enjoyment is just being able to be together!”
- Place the focus on something other than the food. Though food is an important aspect, let the togetherness and gratitude be more at the center this year. The real magic is celebrating together, sharing stories and making memories as a family. The food can just be an added bonus!
- Be respectful of choices people make, even your picky eater, and refrain from chiding or shaming.
- Encourage your picky eater to try new foods but don’t push it or stoke a battle over the issue. Anna Knight, Overland Park mom of two, says, “Encourage them to try new things and foods they don’t think they like, and if it doesn’t work out, don’t sweat it if they fill up on the stuff they do like.” Be sure to celebrate the positive if your picky eater does try something new though!
Even though picky eaters can be frustrating, don’t let it steal your attitude of gratitude during Thanksgiving. After all, Thanksgiving is about being together, celebrating the many blessings in our lives and creating a welcoming environment for all. It may take a little more creativity and patience this year, but celebrate the diversity of tastes and preferences-even if that means adding Goldfish crackers to your Thanksgiving meal this year!
Julie Collett is an Overland Park mom with four kids who all like different things ¦ and can’t understand why she can’t keep a mentally updated list of everyone’s preferences!